4 stars for "I can't look into your eyes, because I'm so much taller than you, and you never grew". -1 star for lack of a scale model of stonehenge dropping from the ceiling.
HOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLYYYYYYYYYY SHHHHHHHHHHIIIIIIIIITTTTTTTTTTT Live Journal:
I know this dude. He used to (still does?) work at a record store in the county I grew up. I saw the name and the hair (yeah, that's his real hair) and was like, "Nah, couldn't be" until I went to his youtube page and got confirmation that it is him. Given these facts, I can only assume all of the footage you have seen is completely real. I'm sure I've met "Jim" as well, as Nathaniel was never without his pack of 80's metal heads that seemed to be sucked in by the gravitational pull of his hair. Don't ever change, man.
Live Journal Update:
After I saw this I reconnected with Nathaniel on Facebook and it appears Nathaniel and James are having a reconciliation of sorts due to their new found Youtube fame. Winters Mistress may have a happy ending after all.